PayPal: Anatomy of a Value Trap
Related content
After 26 years, the Italian stock market hit a new high
When looking at the ranking of the best-performing stock indices globally so far this year, it’s easy at first glance to overlook the Italian stock market, even though the FTSE MIB index has been gradually climbing higher over the past three years and, at the end of May this year, hit a new all-time high for the first time in about twenty-six years. The financial sector carries significant weight in the index; however, the top three best-performing components so far this year are not bank stocks, but rather the shares of a technology company, an energy company, and an industrial firm.
Europe's industrial sector is experiencing a surge in momentum
The rotation away from the U.S. technology sector is becoming increasingly pronounced, with Europe benefiting regionally and cyclical exposures—particularly the industrial segment—benefiting sectorally. Normalizing energy prices, improving growth prospects, a manufacturing sector that appears stronger than in previous periods, and German fiscal stimulus measures are all benefiting European industrial companies, and the iShares STOXX Europe 600 Industrial Goods & Services ETF (EXH4), which tracks these companies, reached a new all-time high yesterday, which we believe presents a favorable trading opportunity.
Our latest read on PayPal’s report confirms that what many long regarded as an undervalued opportunity is, in fact, a classic value trap. Weaker-than-expected quarterly results and guidance, the dismissal of the CEO, and mounting structural industry pressures have collectively shattered investor confidence. As a result, we are removing the stock from our Preferred Stocks List.
PayPal’s share price plunged after the company posted weaker-than-expected numbers in its quarterly release and at the same time dismissed the CEO appointed two and a half years ago, whom the shareholders had expected to deliver a turnaround. We, too, waited too long for that turnaround; in hindsight, we should have removed the name from our Preferred Stocks List in 2025—something we are doing now.
Back in late 2023 we were optimistic on PayPal: it’s a strong brand whose share price had fallen sharply from its pandemic-era highs. There appeared to be real potential for a turnaround, especially with the appointment of the new CEO, Alex Chriss. Over the ensuing two-plus years there were several rallies when it looked as if a growth inflection might be taking hold, and most earnings prints were not outright bad. Even so, the reorganization ultimately ran into roadblocks.
The prior November earnings release should have been a warning sign. The stock initially surged, then reversed and has been sliding back ever since. Based on the latest report, this increasingly looks like a value trap—a stock that screens cheap on financial metrics but is not a good investment because the apparent “cheapness” masks persistent, structural deterioration, preventing a meaningful rerating.
PayPal displays the defining features of a value trap: profitability has been deteriorating for a prolonged period, a problem the (now-ousted) CEO was unable to fix—hence the leadership change. The company, like the broader online payments industry, faces structural challenges: competition is intense, the large tech platforms (Apple Pay, Google Pay) dominate, and numerous fintech entrants crowd the space, eroding margins and constraining growth. Crucially, PayPal has failed to deliver meaningful growth in its higher-margin branded checkout segment. For this year, management guides to at best minimal profit growth, whereas analysts were expecting around an 8% increase.
We’re not saying PayPal is entirely hopeless as an investment. However, we won’t wait to see whether a new CEO can engineer an operational turnaround that would finally spark a sustained share-price recovery. Accordingly, we are removing PayPal from our Preferred Stocks List.
Get more out of your investments!
Global Markets Services
OTP Global Markets offers a broad range of services in the field of local and international money and capital markets.
Read morePrivate Banking Services
Personal care and expertise with OTP Private Banking, along with the knowledge, security, and innovations of a multinational banking group.
Read more